The short version
Immich is free, open source and actively developed, with stable releases since October 2025. It doesn't upload your photos to its developer's cloud; they stay on the server you run. Its phone apps automatically back up your photos and videos to your own server, which adds facial recognition and natural-language search. As of October 2026, Immich's docs list Docker plus at least 6 GB of RAM and 2 CPU cores for that server.
CachePix is a photo catalog app for Mac and Windows. It catalogs the photos on your drives, then syncs a searchable catalog to free iPhone and Android companion apps, so you can browse your archive with the drives unplugged. Your photos never go to the cloud.
The trade-off is real. CachePix does less, and it isn't free. If you need facial recognition, AI search, video or phone backup more than you want to skip the server, pick Immich.
CachePix vs Immich side by side
Immich cells were checked October 6, 2026, against the sources in the caption. CachePix cells describe desktop 0.2.1 and the iOS and Android 1.1.0 apps.
| Feature | CachePix | Immich |
|---|---|---|
| Native desktop app | Yes: Mac with Apple silicon on macOS 12 or later, and 64-bit Windows (x64) | No. You use Immich's web app in a browser, served by the Immich server you run |
| Server to run | None for you to install or run | Required. Its docs list Docker plus at least 6 GB of RAM and 2 CPU cores (8 GB and 4 cores recommended) |
| Phone apps | Yes: iOS 18 or later and Android 9 or later. Free downloads; a CachePix plan is required | Yes: free iPhone and Android apps, plus F-Droid. The iPhone app needs iOS 15.0 or later, per its App Store listing |
| Phone backup | No. CachePix is a catalog, not a backup | Yes, automatically, to your own Immich server |
| Photos already on your drives | Choose Catalog a Folder… and pick a folder or a drive: internal, external or removable | External Libraries. Per Immich's docs, an administrator sets each one up, and the folders must be mounted into the server's Docker container |
| Facial recognition | No. People names come from metadata in your files, or names you type in CachePix | Yes. It groups faces into people you can name and search, on your own server |
| Search | Metadata text. On the computer: filename, people, keywords, caption, headline, title, city, state, sublocation, creator, event and categories. On the phone: filename, people, keywords and caption | AI-powered natural-language search (for example, "dog on a beach") and text inside photos (OCR). Per its FAQ, it creates no visible tags |
| Photo editing | No. CachePix doesn't edit pixels. Cataloging never modifies, moves, renames or deletes your files. CachePix writes metadata only when you edit it, and only the fields you changed, as standard XMP in the file or in a sidecar next to RAW files | Yes: non-destructive crop, rotate and mirror |
| Photo formats | JPEG, PNG, WebP and 15 RAW formats. HEIC and TIFF are cataloged and searchable, with no preview yet | Supports RAW. Its source code recognizes common formats, including Canon CR2/CR3, Sony ARW, Nikon NEF, Fujifilm RAF and DNG |
| Video | No | Yes, with transcoded copies for smooth playback |
| Where your photos live | Your photos, previews and catalog never leave your own computer and phone. CachePix's only online service is your account: email sign-in, the plan check, and Stripe billing in your browser | On the server you run. Its privacy policy says the company has no access to them |
| Open source | No | Yes, under the GNU AGPL v3 |
| Price | $4.99 a month or $29.99 a year after a 14-day free trial, or $99 once for Lifetime | Free. Optional one-time supporter keys cost $25 for a single user and $100 for a whole server (the Family key), per buy.immich.app. You provide the hardware |
What CachePix doesn't do. No facial recognition, AI search, video, photo editing or phone backup, and on Mac it needs Apple silicon. If you need any of those, see all comparisons.
Immich on Windows, and an Immich alternative for Windows
Immich's server runs in Docker, and it can run on a Windows PC through Docker Desktop. As of October 2026, though, Immich's install docs recommend Linux and say Windows and macOS hosts (run through Docker Desktop) are "strongly discouraged". Per Immich's download page, the server installs with Docker Compose or Kubernetes, and community guides cover NAS platforms such as unRaid and TrueNAS SCALE.
Want an Immich alternative for Windows without Docker Desktop? As of October 2026, Immich has no native desktop app, so on a PC you use its web app in a browser. CachePix runs on 64-bit Windows (x64) as a regular desktop app. Download CachePix for Windows or an Apple silicon Mac.
Immich vs PhotoPrism vs no server for you to run
Also looking at PhotoPrism? Here's how the three line up on setup.
| Question | Immich | PhotoPrism | CachePix |
|---|---|---|---|
| Needs a server? | Yes: at least 6 GB of RAM and 2 CPU cores, per its docs | Yes: one you run (at least 2 CPU cores and 3 GB of RAM recommended), or paid managed hosting from its partner PikaPods | No server for you to install or run |
| Desktop app? | No: a web app in your browser | No: it runs in your browser, and you can add its web app (PWA) to your desktop | Yes: Mac and Windows |
| Its own phone app? | Yes: iPhone and Android | No app in the App Store or Google Play. You use its web app (PWA), and third-party apps such as PhotoSync can upload to your server | Yes: iPhone and Android, plan required |
| Facial recognition? | Yes | Yes, in all editions | No |
| Free and open source? | Yes, under the GNU AGPL v3 | Yes: the Community Edition is free to self-host and open source under the AGPL. Its standard Docker image and member features use PhotoPrism's separate Plus License | No: paid, with a 14-day free trial on Monthly and Annual |
Want PhotoPrism in more detail? See CachePix vs PhotoPrism.
When Immich is the better pick
If one of these is why you're shopping, choose Immich.
- Phone backup. Immich's phone apps automatically back up photos and videos to your own Immich server. CachePix doesn't read your camera roll.
- Facial recognition. It groups faces into people you can name and search.
- AI search. Natural-language search (for example, "dog on a beach") that runs on your own server, plus search for text inside photos (OCR).
- One library across your devices. Your other devices view the library through your own Immich server.
- Video and basic edits. It plays videos, and it can crop, rotate and mirror without changing the original file.
- Free and open source. All features are included, and its developers say no features will ever be paywalled. Your cost is the hardware you run it on.
- A home server or NAS you already run. That's where Immich usually lives, installed with Docker, and its docs recommend Linux.
When CachePix is the better Immich alternative
CachePix suits a family archive that already lives on external drives, when you want it on your phone without a server in the house to look after.
- Nothing to host. Looking for Immich without Docker? CachePix installs like any desktop app: no Docker, no container, no mounted folders, no admin step.
- Drives cataloged where they sit. Choose Catalog a Folder… and pick a folder or a drive. CachePix samples about 24 photos first and estimates the preview store's size.
- Drives can stay in the drawer. Browse and search your catalog with the drives unplugged and the computer at home. CachePix checks your plan online at least once every 14 days. Full-size originals stay on your drives; the phone carries thumbnails and HD previews.
- An Immich alternative for iOS and Android. The free CachePix phone apps need a CachePix plan. They show the catalog your computer builds and don't back up your camera roll.
- The metadata you already wrote. It reads IPTC and XMP from Photo Mechanic or Lightroom, including sidecars next to RAW files. Words combine, so "Ana beach" finds photos that match both.
- No facial recognition, by design. For people who'd rather their photo app didn't scan faces.
- A one-time option. Lifetime is $99. Pay once. No renewals. Compare plans on CachePix pricing.
On the library we measured, 190,566 photos (885.66 GB) in two folders on one external drive, the thumbnails took 8.03 GB on an iPhone. The method is in how much space it uses on your phone.
Not a backup. CachePix is a catalog, not a backup. It makes your archive findable. It doesn't make a second copy, so keep backing up your drives.
Common questions
Does Immich run on Windows?
Yes, its server can, through Docker Desktop. As of October 2026, though, Immich's install docs recommend Linux and say Windows hosts are "strongly discouraged", and Immich has no native desktop app, so on a PC you use its web app in a browser. CachePix installs as a native app on 64-bit Windows.
Can I use Immich without a server?
No. Immich's apps need an Immich server that you run yourself, usually installed with Docker on a home server, NAS or always-on computer, and its app listings say you "will need to run/manage the server on your own". CachePix is a desktop app for Mac and Windows, and there's no server for you to install or run.
Is Immich free?
Yes. Immich is free and open source, with all features included; you supply the hardware. As of October 2026, optional supporter keys cost $25 for a single user and $100 for a whole server (the Family key), per buy.immich.app. CachePix is $4.99 a month or $29.99 a year after a 14-day free trial (card required), or $99 once for Lifetime.
Does CachePix back up my phone like Immich does?
No. CachePix is a catalog, not a backup, and the phone app doesn't read your camera roll. Immich's phone apps automatically back up photos and videos to your own Immich server. CachePix works the other way: the catalog syncs one way, from your computer to your phone, over your local network. Keep backing up your drives.
Immich or PhotoPrism: which needs less setup?
Both need a server; PhotoPrism lists lower hardware needs. As of October 2026, it recommends at least 2 CPU cores and 3 GB of RAM to self-host, while Immich's docs list at least 6 GB of RAM and 2 cores. PhotoPrism also offers paid managed hosting through its partner PikaPods. CachePix has no server for you to install or run.
Keep reading
See all comparisons, or the FAQ on do I need a server.
Compare
CachePix vs PhotoPrism
The other self-hosted option, row by row.
Compare
Google Photos alternative without the cloud
Skip the self-hosted server. Your library stays on your own drives, browsable on your phone.
Plans
CachePix pricing
Monthly, Annual or Lifetime.
Get started
Download CachePix
Apple silicon Mac or 64-bit Windows, plus the phone apps.
Last checked . Immich is actively developed, so check its site before you decide.
Sources
Immich and PhotoPrism official pages first, then the independent coverage behind the facts on this page. XDA Developers, How-To Geek, Android Police and MakeUseOf share a parent company (Valnet).
- Immich download page. Immich (official site). Checked October 6, 2026.
- Immich install requirements. Immich documentation (official). Checked October 6, 2026.
- Immich External Libraries. Immich documentation (official). Checked October 6, 2026.
- Immich mobile backup. Immich documentation (official). Checked October 6, 2026.
- Immich facial recognition. Immich documentation (official). Checked October 6, 2026.
- Immich searching. Immich documentation (official). Checked October 6, 2026.
- Immich editing. Immich documentation (official). Checked October 6, 2026.
- Immich FAQ. Immich documentation (official). Checked October 6, 2026.
- Support the project. Immich documentation (official). Checked October 6, 2026.
- Immich purchase page. Immich (official site). Checked October 6, 2026.
- Immich privacy policy. Immich (official site). Checked October 6, 2026.
- Immich roadmap. Immich (official site). Checked October 6, 2026.
- Immich supported file types (source code). Immich official repository on GitHub. Checked October 6, 2026.
- Immich on the App Store. App Store listing (official). Checked October 6, 2026.
- Immich on Google Play. Google Play listing (official). Checked October 6, 2026.
- PhotoPrism setup. PhotoPrism documentation (official). Checked October 6, 2026.
- PhotoPrism mobile app (PWA). PhotoPrism documentation (official). Checked October 6, 2026.
- PhotoPrism features. PhotoPrism (official site). Checked October 6, 2026.
- PhotoPrism membership FAQ. PhotoPrism (official site). Checked October 6, 2026.
- PhotoPrism open source FAQ. PhotoPrism (official site). Checked October 6, 2026.
- I (finally) ditched Google Photos for self-hosted; here's how it went. Android Authority (Robert Triggs), January 10, 2026.
- How I ditched Google Photos for my own private self-hosted alternative, for free. ZDNET (Jack Wallen), December 29, 2025.
- Immich 2.3 Adds Multilingual OCR Models. Linuxiac (Bobby Borisov), November 19, 2025.
- Immich 3.0 Released with Big Upgrades for Self-Hosted Photo Libraries. Linuxiac (Bobby Borisov), July 2, 2026.
- Immich 3.2 Photo and Video Management Solution Released with Redesigned Search. Linuxiac (Bobby Borisov), September 13, 2026.
- Immich Introduces Licensing in the Latest Update. Linuxiac (Bobby Borisov), July 19, 2024.
- Immich. Wikipedia (Dutch edition, crowd-edited), last revised July 6, 2026.
- Google Photos Alternative Immich Gets First Stable Release. How-To Geek, October 2, 2025.
- I stopped paying for Google Photos the moment I discovered this self-hosted alternative. How-To Geek, April 17, 2026.
- Why Immich succeeded where every other Google Photos alternative failed. How-To Geek, July 16, 2026.
- I switched to Immich, but Google Photos still wins on these 5 fronts. How-To Geek, July 19, 2026.
- I self-hosted my own Google Photos replacement, and it's better than what I was paying for. XDA Developers, March 17, 2026.
- I mounted my Immich library in Finder, and now I never open the web app. XDA Developers, July 16, 2026.
- I used an old graphics card to add AI features to my Immich server, and it's now smarter than Google Photos. XDA Developers, July 16, 2026.
- Immich 3.0 finally let me delete the Google Photos app for good. XDA Developers, July 22, 2026.
- I replaced Google Photos with Immich, and my entire photo library finally stays under my control. XDA Developers, August 23, 2026.
- I ditched Google One for self-hosted Immich on a mini PC, and photo backup is finally instant. XDA Developers, September 25, 2026.
- Immich finally lets me lift text out of my photos without opening a laptop. Android Police, August 11, 2026.
- PhotoPrism. heise download (heise online), record last updated May 26, 2026.
- PhotoPrism AI-Powered Photos App Gets Better Face Detection. Linuxiac (Bobby Borisov), September 24, 2026.
- What Is PhotoPrism? How to Use the AI-Powered Photo App. MakeUseOf (Danny Maiorca), March 8, 2024.
- This self-hosted app sorted my messy photo library in minutes. MakeUseOf (Jayric Maning), November 9, 2025.
- How I built a Google Photos alternative on my NAS with PhotoPrism. XDA Developers (Adam Conway), April 11, 2024.
- I finally replaced Synology Photos with PhotoPrism for these 4 major frustrations. XDA Developers (Chandraveer Mathur), November 21, 2025.
- I ditched Google Photos for self-hosting and discovered 5 hidden costs nobody mentions. How-To Geek (Jorge A. Aguilar), April 14, 2026.